Research Guide: International Commercial Arbitration
Last Updated June 12, 2013
The purpose of this research guide is to provide a brief overview of International Commercial Arbitration (“ICA”) and the resources available on the topic, in Columbia's Diamond Law Library, through the library homepage, and on the Internet.
For additional assistance in finding ICA materials at the library, please do not hesitate to contact the reference librarians at the Reference Desk. Please consult the law library homepage for general library information and reference desk hours.
ICA is a method of resolving disputes through an arbitration proceeding heard by one or more arbitrators, instead of pursuing resolution of the dispute through an applicable court system. There are many reasons why parties may prefer arbitration to litigation. One, parties may wish to avoid the high costs of litigation, the uncertainty of proceedings in foreign (to the party) court systems and laws, and the potential difficulties in enforcing foreign judgments. Two, arbitrations are normally binding and usually do not allow for an extensive appeal process. Three, arbitral awards are normally confidential, unlike most court decisions issued in litigation. Finally, the parties to the dispute traditionally select the arbitrators to hear the dispute--which allows for the selection of arbitrators well versed in the subject-matter of the dispute at issue.
Parties normally choose ICA to resolve disputes when drafting contracts and other agreements--a clause selecting the institution or arbitral rules to be used in any future disputes can be added to the agreements during negotiations.
The following is a selected list of the print resources available at the Diamond Law Library on ICA. There are many more print resources available. See the library catalog and search for the subject: International Commercial Arbitration.
1. Comparison of International Arbitration Rules 4th Floor, K2400 .C67 2008
Written by Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP, this publication is a chart comparing the model clauses and rules of the: International Chamber of Commerce (the "ICC") Arbitration Rules (1998), American Arbitration Association ("AAA")/International Center for Dispute Resolution ("ICDR") International Arbitration Rules (2008), London Court of International Arbitration ("LCIA") Rules (1998), Stockholm Chamber of Commerce Arbitration Institute ("SCCAI") Arbitration Rules (2007), International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes ("ICSID") Arbitration Rules (2006), United Nations Commission on International Trade Law ("UNICITRAL") Arbitration Rules (1976) and Center for Public Resources ("CPR") International Arbitration Rules (2007). The first five sets of rules are institutional arbitration rules and the last two are ad hoc arbitration rules. Please note that the chart maybe slightly out-of-date, as the ICC, AAA/ICDR, SCCAI and UNICITRAL rules have been amended since the chart was published in 2008. Links to the updated rules are available below in Arbitration Proceedings & Institutional Bodies.
2. International Chamber of Commerce Arbitration 2nd Floor. JX6279 C8441 2000
Written by W. Laurence Craig, William W. Park and Jan Paulsson, this book addresses arbitration before the ICC Court of Arbitration. The book begins with a general discussion of the ICC and arbitration procedures. It continues with an extensive discussion of the clauses of arbitration agreements and the selection (and challenge) of arbitrators. There is also a brief (and easy to understand) discussion of the relationship between ICC arbitration and the New York Convention (see Conventions and Protocols below), as well as the impact other treaties may have on the New York Convention.
The appendices contain a variety of statistics on ICC arbitration, including amounts in dispute, the costs of arbitration and the nationalities of the arbitrators and parties, through 1999. The authors included an extensive Table of Cases (with citations to the case as well as the discussion in the text) as well as a similar Table of Arbitral Awards and a Table of Authorities.
3. International Commercial Arbitration 3rd Floor Reserve. K7690 .B67 2009
Written by Gary Born, a leading practitioner of ICA, this is a two-volume treatise. Volume I contains an extensive history of ICA, an overview of the major conventions and treaties, and an overview of the major institutional arbitration organizations. The remainder of Volume I provides a substantive overview of the different aspects of an international arbitration, including choice of law and enforcement issues.
Volume II includes chapters on the substance of arbitration agreements as well as the selection of arbitrators and the procedure for challenging arbitrators. Volume II also includes extensive lists of books, articles, legislation, treaties and UN documents regarding ICA. There is also an index of the arbitral awards referenced in the text.
4. Practitioner's Handbook on International Commercial Arbitration 2nd Edition 3rd Floor Reserve. K2400 .P733 2009
Edited by Frank-Bernd Weigand, this is a one volume handbook. The book begins with a general introduction to ICA (and an extensive bibliography) and follows with separate chapters on ICA in Austria, Belgium, China and Hong Kong, England, France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Singapore, Sweden, Switzerland and the United States. Each country chapter also contains a thorough bibliography. The handbook concludes with chapters of commentaries on the UNICITRAL Model Law on ICA, the Arbitration Rules of the ICC, the UNICITRAL rules, the ICDR International Commercial Arbitration Rules and the LCIA Rules. Geared toward practitioners, the country chapters and commentary are to the point and succinct. There is also a Table of Cases and subject index.
Written by S.I. Strong, a former practitioner of ICA, this book is written for a novice in the ICA field. Chapter 1 sets forth some of the unique issues in researching ICA, while Chapter 2 explains the different sources of law involved (and sources of law that do not apply to ICA, but are commonly assumed to apply). Chapter 3 discusses where to find the various sources of law and Chapter 4 discusses customs in practicing ICA. Chapter 5 provides an extensive bibliography regarding ICA--including treatises, journals, conventions, treaties and electronic resources.
For more information regarding finding monographs on ICA, please see the research guide Finding Books and Articles on International and Foreign Law.
1. World Arbitration Reporter 3rd Floor Reserve. K2400 .W672
A five volume publication. Volumes 1 and 1A contain information and commentary on the arbitration laws of each applicable country. Volume 2 contains information and commentary on national arbitration institutions, normally with the applicable rules for such institution attached as an appendix. Volume 3 covers international arbitration institutions (with applicable rules attached as an appendix). Finally, Volume 4 covers treaties, bilateral and regional agreements (with the text of appropriate documents attached as appendices).
The following is a selected list of the ICA periodicals available at the Diamond Law Library. There are many more periodicals available. See the library catalog and search for the subject: International Commercial Arbitration -- Periodicals.
1. The American review of international arbitration (1990 to present) 3rd Floor Reserve and Cellar. JX1 Am334.
Published on a quarterly basis, this journal publishes articles (written by practitioners and academics) as well as book reviews of books on ICA.
Published on a quarterly basis, this is the journal of the Swiss Arbitration Association ("ASA"). Issues can include articles written by practitioners and academics, cases from Swiss courts, cases from foreign jurisdictions, arbitral awards and orders, book reviews and information regarding ASA. Articles can be published in English, French or German.
3. The ICC International Court of Arbitration Bulletin (1990 to present) 3rd Floor Reserve and Cellar. JX1 Ic15.
Published twice a year, this is the publication of the International Chamber of Commerce International Court of Arbitration. Issues may contain reports and information regarding the ICC, new rules or regulations regarding ICA and excerpts from ICC arbitral awards.
4. ICSID Review Foreign Investment Law Journal (1986 to present) 3rd Floor Reserve and Cellar. JX1 Ic7.
Published twice a year, this is the publication of ICSID. Issues may contain articles (sometimes on a particular subject or theme), student articles, reports and book reviews.
5. International Arbitration Law Review (1997 to present) 3rd Floor Reserve and Cellar. JX1 In823.
Published six times a year, this journal includes shorter articles and news relating to ICA. Each article has keywords associated with it, which can be used to locate similar articles via the annual index.
6. Journal of International Arbitration (1984 to present) 3rd Floor Reserve and Cellar. JX1 J7825.
Also available electronically (1995 to present) through Pegasus.
Published six times a year, this publication includes shorter articles (from practitioners and academics) and the International Arbitration Events Calendar.
Individual journal articles on ICA can also be found by using periodical indexes (follow the link for a complete list of periodical indexes available at the law library).
Here are some search terms to get started:
For more information regarding finding journal articles on ICA, please see the research guide Finding Books and Articles on International and Foreign Law. The ProQuest database (available to the Columbia University community) may be especially helpful for finding news articles regarding ICA.
ICAs are normally governed by conventions signed by member states. The following is a list of the major conventions in ICA today. Please also see the World Arbitration Reporter (discussed in Reporters above) for additional ICA conventions and treaties.
1. Geneva Protocol and Geneva Convention
Two early modern agreements on ICA are the 1923 Geneva Protocol (27 L.N.T.S. 157, from HeinOnline, available to the CLS community) and the 1927 Geneva Convention (92 L.N.T.S. 301, from HeinOnline, available to the CLS community).
2. New York Convention
Replacing the Geneva Protocol and Geneva Convention is the United Nations Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, otherwise known as the New York Convention. Once a state becomes a party to the New York Convention, they are no longer subject to the Geneva Protocol and Geneva Convention.
The list of parties to the New York Convention and any declarations or reservations made by such party to the convention are available at through the UN Treaty Collection.
3. European Convention on ICA
The European Convention on ICA deals with arbitration agreements, arbitral procedures and awards.
The list of parties to the European Convention on ICA and any declarations or reservations made by such party to the convention are available through the UN Treaty Collection.
4. Inter-American Convention on International Commercial Arbitration
This convention was entered into in 1975 among the United States and most South American nations. It is also known as the Panama Convention. The signatories to the convention can be found through the website of the General Secretariat of the Organization of American States.
5. International Center for the Settlement of Investment Disputes Convention
This convention is also known as the ICSID Convention or the Washington Convention of 1965. It deals with investment disputes between a state (or some state entities) and an individual who is a national of another state that signed the ICSID convention.
The language of the convention, rules and regulations regarding arbitrations through the can be found through the website of the World Bank as well as a relatively current list of parties to the ICSID convention.
6. Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters
7. Council Regulation (EC) No. 44/2001 of December 22, 2000 on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters
This regulation deals with the issue of enforcement of arbitral decisions for members of the European Union.
8. Inter-American Convention on International Commercial Arbitration
Bilateral Investment Treaties
Bilateral Investment Treaties ("BITs") are treaties between two countries that often contain clauses allowing foreign investors to require international arbitration of some categories of investment disputes with the state in which the foreign investment has been made. These treaties often have provisions relating to the enforceability of international arbitration awards.
ICSID’s website contains a database of bilateral investment treaties. One can browse by country or year of signature. One can also search for a particular treaty between two countries. This database consists of information provided by the countries which enter into such BITs and is therefore not necessarily complete.
The looseleaf publication Investment Promotion and Protection Treaties (Fourth Floor, K1112 .I581) is complied by ICSID and contains the text of the bilateral investment treaties that ICSID has been provided by the signatories to such treaties.
The United Nationals Conference on Trade and Development ("UNCTAD") website has a feature where one can obtain a list (as of June 1, 2013) of all the bilateral investment treaties entered into by a particular country, with date of signature and date of entry into force. The website also has a database of BITs which one can search by country--one can search for all BITs entered into by a particular country or search for a BIT between two specific countries.
Individual countries will sometimes provide a list of their BITs. The list of BITs currently in force by the United States can be found at the website of the Trade Compliance Center, along with links to the text of such treaties.
UNICITRAL Model Law on ICA
UNICITRAL keeps track of which countries have adopted ICA legislation consistent with the language of the Model Law.
There are two types of arbitrations—institutional and adhoc. Institutional arbitrations are overseen by an institutional body and controlled by arbitration rules specific to the particular institution (which can also play an administrative role), while adhoc arbitrations are conducted by individual arbitrators, normally controlled by the particular arbitration rules agreed to by the parties in the contract of the underlying dispute and potentially any applicable national arbitration legislation.
In an institutional arbitration proceeding, the arbitration bodies will normally administer the resolution of the dispute, as opposed to resolving the disputes directly. In other words, the arbitrators are selected by the parties to the dispute (although often confirmed by the institutional body and sometimes the arbitrators are chosen by the institutional body), but the arbitrators are not part of the institutional body itself.
The following is a list (and links to) some of the major international arbitration bodies:
1. International Chamber of Commerce (“ICC”): (http://www.iccwbo.org/court/)
The ICC publishes rules of arbitration to govern ICA disputes. The 2012 version of the rules are available on the ICC website in Arabic, Chinese, English, French, German, Portuguese and Spanish. Only the English and French versions are official versions. The 1998 version of the arbitration rules are also available.
2. London Court of International Arbitration (“LCIA”): (http://www.lcia.org/)
Arbitrations are governed by the LCIA rules, most recently revised in 1998. The LCIA provides a brief summary of the 1998 rules. According to the LCIA website, the 1998 arbitration rules are currently under review.
3. International Centre for Dispute Resolution (“ICDR”): (http://www.adr.org/)
The ICDR administers all of the American Arbitration Association’s international arbitrations. The ICDR’s rules, the ICDR International Dispute Resolution Procedures, are available in English, Spanish, French, German, Portuguese, Chinese and Italian.
4. Swiss Chamber of Commerce ("SCC"): (https://www.sccam.org/sa/en/)
The SCC conducts arbitrations based on the Swiss Rules of International Arbitration. Copies of the rules in a variety of languages (including English, Chinese and Arabic) are available on the SCC website.
The website of the SCC states that the Swiss Rules of International Arbitration are based on the UNICITRAL rules, with some modifications. The SCC has published a comparison of the rules.
5. Vienna International Arbitral Centre ("VIAC"): (http://www.internationales-schiedsgericht.at/en.html)
VIAC coordinates arbitrations based on the VIAC Rules from 2006.
The entire VIAC website (http://www.internationales-schiedsgericht.at/) and arbitration rules are available in English, German, Czech and Russian.
6. Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre ("HKIAC"): (http://www.hkiac.org/)
HKIAC administers arbitrations pursuant to the HKIAC Administered Arbitration Rules which are available in English, Chinese, Korean and Japanese. The English language version is the official version. HKIAC states that their rules are based on the UNICITRAL arbitration rules.
7. Chinese International Economic and Trade Arbitration Centre ("CIETAC"): (http://www.cietac.org/index.cms)
CIETAC administers arbitrations in accordance with the CIETAC Arbitration Rules. The rules are available in Chinese, English, French, German, Japanese, Korean, Portuguese and Spanish.
8. Cairo Regional Centre for International Commercial Arbitration ("CRCICA"): (http://www.crcica.org.eg/)
CRCICA administers arbitrations based on the CRCICA rules which it states are based on the UNICITRAL rules with minor modifications. Copies of the rules are available in English and Arabic.
9. Stockholm Chamber of Commerce Arbitration Institute ("SCCAI"): (http://www.sccinstitute.com/)
The SCCAI administers arbitrations in accordance with its rules, the SCCAI Arbitration Rules or other arbitration rules agreed to by the parties to the dispute. The SCCAI Arbitration rules are available in English, Swedish, Russian, German, Arabic, Chinese, Spanish and French, but the English version is the official version.
Institutional arbitration bodies can choose to administer arbitrations dealing with a particular subject matter. The following are two of such institutional bodies:
1. World Intellectual Property Organization
The World Intellectual Property Organization (“WIPO”) focuses on intellectual property disputes. However, disputes of any topic may be heard by WIPO. For more information on WIPO, please see the Resource Guide for Researching Intellectual Property Law in an International Context.
2. Court of Arbitration of Sport
Recent arbitral decisions are available in English or French in .pdf format. An archive of non-confidential decisions since 1986 are in a database, also in .pdf format. One can browse decisions by sport or by year and can do keyword searching.
Ad hoc arbitrations are not conducted under the auspices of an institutional body--rather they are organized by the parties to the dispute.
The UNICITRAL Arbitration Rules are designed to be used in ad hoc arbitrations. The text of the UNICITRAL rules (most recently revised in 2010) are available on the UNICITRAL website.
The original UNICITRAL Arbitration Rules were adopted in 1976. The text of the 1976 version can also be found on the UNICITRAL website.
The CPR created the CPR Rules for Non-Administered Arbitration of International Disputes and Commentary, which were most recently revised in 2007.
In contrast to court opinions, arbitration submissions and awards are often confidential. This makes locating the awards much more difficult than locating court opinions. However, there are a variety of electronic databases and print reporters that publish arbitral awards. These awards are sometimes excerpts (and confidential information has been removed).
Part of the United Nations website, this database contains pdf versions of the Reports of International Arbitral Awards (“RIAA”), currently through Volume XXIX (2012). Each volume contains a table of contents, index and foreword explaining the awards published in the particular volume. One can search by volume of the RIAA or by party to a dispute. One can also conduct a full-text search of the volumes.
The RIAA is limited to arbitral decisions between states or between states and international organizations. There are also some decisions between individuals and states in which the individual has a sponsoring state.
The awards are published in English and French (and normally both)--with footnotes stating when the translation has been done by the United Nations Secretariat. The RIAA publishes recent awards, as well as older awards (previously published elsewhere) which have become less accessible over time. There are sometimes maps published in connection with an award--such maps are only available in the print version.
2. Case Law on Uncitral Texts (“CLOUT”)
Part of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law website, this is a freely accessible database of court decisions and arbitral awards relating to:
Decisions and awards are collected by national correspondents of each state that is a party to one of the conventions listed above and/or has adopted legislation based on one of the model laws listed above. The correspondents then prepare abstracts of such decisions and awards. The abstracts are published intermittently and are made available in the six official UN languages: Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian and Spanish.
Abstracts can be browsed (by date of publication) or searched by a number of subjects: legislative text and article, date, country, court, parties and keyword.
3. ICSID Cases
ICSID provides lists of pending and concluded cases to browse, with fairly extensive information about each case. Citations to decisions (if publicly available) are also provided. Under "Search Online Decisions and Awards" there is also a list of, and links to, the publicly available information or decisions from ICSID cases starting in the 1980's. By selecting the advanced search option, one can search by party, type of document, case number, time period and language.
UNCTAD provides a database of information regarding arbitral awards (concluded or pending) that one can browse or search. There are a variety of facets available (parties, home country of investor, type of investment, rules etc.). However, the search feature is extremely slow (and isn't always working) and there are no links to the actual awards.
5. Collection of ICC Arbitral Awards Fourth Floor, K2400.A47 C65
There are five volumes of ICC Court of Arbitration cases, covering years 1974-2007. Each volume contains abstracts of awards and commentary on the Court of Arbitration cases that have been previously published in the Yearbook Commercial Arbitration and the Journal du Droit International. There are indexes to search by date (and case number) and by subject. Abstracts and commentaries are available in English and French (but not always both).
This resource is also available on Westlaw (Database ICC-AWARDS) covering the years 1974-2004.
6. Yearbook Commercial Arbitration Fourth Floor, K2400.A15 Y43
Starting in 1976 and published annually, this publication provides references to new or amended foreign arbitration rules, a short description of recent ICA developments in relevant countries and, most importantly, arbitral awards and court decisions. Many of the awards are excerpts, but the complete award or decision is available at Kluwer Arbitration.com (which is a subscription database available to the CLS community). The awards are organized by arbitral body and the court decisions are organized by the ICA convention that is relevant to the case. For ease of searching, there is a subject index for arbitral awards.
7. ICSID Reports 3rd Floor Reserve, JX1976.S1 Ic71 1993
Currently a 15 volume set, the ICSID Reports publish arbitral reports (in full text when available) by tribunals or ad hoc committees based on the ICSID Convention. Volume 1 contains cases commenced between 1972 and 1981 and Volume 15 covers cases commenced between 1998 and 2004. Each volume contains a table of cases published in the particular volume, a table of cases published in all existing volumes and a digest for cases published in the particular volume. There is also a subject index at the back of each volume. Volumes 1 through 10 have cumulative subject indexes, while volumes 11 through 15 have individual subject indexes. All reports (either full-text or excerpts) are printed in English. For each report, the editors have added headings (in bold) indicating the main issues of law and a summary of the proceedings.
8. World Trade and Arbitration Materials
This publication is available in print (starting with Volume 6 1993/1994 to present) and online through Kluwer Law International (Volume 9 1997 to present, although missing Volume 10). The contents of the online issues appear to be pdf scans of the printed version, but missing the cover page and the table of contents. This journal publishes some arbitration awards and information on arbitration statutes and legislation (in addition to reports relating to trade policy in various countries).
This print publication contains information and commentaries on awards and issues relating to international arbitration, as well as some full-text awards and other publications. The "Cases in this Issue" chart on the inside cover page of each issue indicates which full-text documents are available in the publication. Other full-text documents are available at Mealeys Online for a fee (search using the document numbers provided in the print version).
Mealeys Online has a search box where one can search for articles in Mealey's International Arbitration Report (be certain to select the publication to search), using keywords and date limitations. The articles are available online for a fee.
This publication is also available through Lexis Nexis under the International Arbitration tab as International Arbitration: Mealey's Litigation Report. Links to the various documents referenced in the articles are also available.
10. Subscription Databases
Arbitral awards are also available through the subscription databases listed below (available to members of the CLS community).
There are several subscription databases available to the CLS community for ICA:
This database includes a large number of books, including Born's International Commercial Arbitration, Yearbook Commercial Arbitration and Redfern and Hunter on International Arbitration. One can browse the books through the table of contents or search in particular sources (using the advanced search feature). There are also several journals available through this database. The full-text of many ICA conventions, national legislation, rules and BITs can be browsed as well. In addition, there is a collection of New York Convention decisions, organized by article of the convention. Kluwer also has a blog with posts by practitioners and scholars in the ICA field. The blog is available without a subscription to the database.
Using the advanced search feature, one can search for different types of documents (awards, rules, commentary etc.), party, source and organization (among others).
LexisNexis has an "International Arbitration" tab which includes databases such as: International Arbitration: Mealey's Litigation Report (starting in 1993) and the journal American Review of International Arbitration (from 1996). There is also a database of U.S. Treaties. See the International Arbitration tab in LexisNexis for a full list of available databases.
Under the Alternative Dispute Resolution area of practice, Westlaw provides a number of ICA databases including: International Commercial Arbitration-Cases (ICA-CASES) which includes published and unpublished cases from a number of countries, a variety of ICA treatises and rules and ICA journals. See the Alternative Dispute Resolution section in Westlaw for a full list of available databases.
This database provides both news articles on investment arbitration and copies of the underlying arbitration documents. One can browse new articles by topic, for example, ICC Rules, NAFTA or Environmental Disputes (among many others) and download pdf copies of the documents mentioned in the news articles. The news articles are compiled into newsletters which can be downloaded as pdfs. There is no search feature in the database. Instead, the database suggests searching the Investment Treaty Arbitration website for publicly available documents (to which Investment Arbitration Reporter contributes documents). The Investment Treaty Arbitration website only has a basic search box, there are no advanced search features.
Transnational Dispute Management is an online journal published approximately 4 to 5 times a year, focusing on international arbitration. Issues can be browsed (or downloaded as pdfs) and articles can be browsed by topic or author. There are search features (regular and advanced). The advanced search feature gives the option of full-text searching, but limited to a particular category of articles. The database also includes a variety of documents--arbitration agreements, legislation, awards and cases that can be browsed or searched. The most helpful browsing capability is by country.
Conducting research on ICA will often require research into the arbitration laws of individual countries. Although such laws are beyond the scope of this research guide, the World Arbitration Reporter (discussed in Reporters, above) contains information and commentary on the arbitration laws of many countries. The American Society of International Law International Commercial Arbitration research guide contains links to many national arbitration laws.
For more information, please see the following research guides on ICA:
Cornell Law Library. International Commercial Arbitration
Georgetown Law Library. International Commercial Arbitration Research Guide
Miccioli, Gloria. The American Society of International Law. International Commercial Arbitration
Please send comments regarding this guide to Alison P. Sherwin, Reference Librarian, Columbia University, Diamond Law Library, at email@example.com